Journal

Fibreglass or Vinyl Liner? Choosing an Inground Pool in Ottawa

Pool with a blue speckled liner, lounge chairs and a low raised stone feature on a patio beside the back of a house

We build vinyl liner pools on steel walls and fibreglass pools. Both can give you a good backyard pool. The right one for you depends on the shape you want, how the yard can be reached and how you feel about upkeep over the years. Here's what separates them.

What is a vinyl liner pool?

A vinyl liner pool is built in place. Wall panels are set up in the excavation, the floor is shaped in the ground, and a vinyl liner made to measure for that pool is fitted inside. The liner holds the water and gives the pool its colour and pattern.

What is a fibreglass pool?

A fibreglass pool is a one-piece shell made in a factory mould. It arrives at your home ready to install and is set into the excavation. The shell's shape, size, depth and built-in steps come from the mould, so you choose from the models the manufacturer makes.

Which gives you more choice of shape and size?

Usually the vinyl liner pool. Because the walls are set up on site and the liner is made for the finished pool, the outline and the depth can follow the yard more closely.

A fibreglass pool trades that freedom for a finished shell. If one of the manufacturer's models fits your yard and the way you swim, you get a shape and step layout that are already worked out. If none fits, a vinyl liner pool is the way to get the shape you have in mind.

Can a fibreglass shell reach my backyard?

This is often the deciding question. A fibreglass shell travels in one piece on a truck and is usually lifted over the house or fence by crane. Overhead wires, mature trees and the space at the street all matter. A vinyl liner pool arrives in parts, so the main limit is getting an excavator into the yard.

We look at access during the site review, before a pool type is settled. It's one of the reasons we draw the pool, the access route and the order of work on the same plan.

How do they feel underfoot?

Vinyl is soft to the touch, and many people like how it feels on the pool floor and steps. Fibreglass has a smooth, hard finish that is easy to brush. Neither is better in itself. If you can, stand in a pool of each type before you decide.

What upkeep should I expect?

A vinyl liner wears and will need replacing at some point in the pool's life. Sharp objects and pool toys with hard edges can also damage it. When the time comes, liner replacement is part of what we do: we measure the pool and fit a new liner.

Fibreglass has no liner to replace. Its smooth surface gives dirt less to cling to, which makes regular brushing quicker. With either type, water chemistry and the yearly opening and closing still need care.

What about Ottawa winters?

Either pool is closed and covered for the cold months, and snow lies on the yard for much of the year. That makes the patio, stone and planting around the pool just as important as the pool itself, because that's what you look at from the house until spring.

Ottawa ground also freezes and thaws through the fall and the spring. Stone and grades beside a pool that sit on a thin base can heave and shift, so the base, drainage and finished grades belong in the design whichever pool you choose.

Which costs more?

There's no fixed answer, and we don't work from a set price list. The size and shape of the pool, how hard the yard is to reach, the features you add and the patio around the water all change the price. Each project is estimated from its own approved design.

How to choose

Start with the yard, not the pool type. Decide where the pool sits, how you'll get to it from the back door and how much room is left for seating and planting. Then ask which pool type fits that plan, and whether a fibreglass shell can reach the spot.

We design and build custom inground pools with the patio and planting around them, from one plan. Send us the address, a few photos of the backyard and the way in, and tell us if you're leaning towards a vinyl liner or a fibreglass pool. We'll help you work out which suits the yard.